Should prostitution be legalized - Free Essay Example

Sample details Pages: 7 Words: 1960 Downloads: 1 Date added: 2019/06/23 Category Society Essay Level High school Tags: Prostitution Essay Did you like this example? One article reads, In Munich, for instance, streetwalking is restricted to nine designated areas of the city. In two of these areas, streetwalkers may ply their trade at any time of day. In the other seven, prostitutes are allowed on the streets only between 8 pm and 6 am. Prostitutes who solicit and negotiate off the street may practice at any time of day in any part of Munich, except in the city center (Yondorf, 1979). Prostitution has been legalized in many European countries including, Austria, Denmark, England, Holland, Italy, Norway, Sweden and West Germany (Yondorf, 1979). Brothels were also legalized in Nevada in 1971 and theres an estimated 21 in existence today. Prostitution is legal in certain countries and now the US is starting to ponder the question of legalized prostitution. The question it, should it be? Don’t waste time! Our writers will create an original "Should prostitution be legalized" essay for you Create order For prostitution strengths/weaknesses Weitzer notes that there are around 90,000 arrests made every year in the US for the violation of prostitution laws. Studies have shown that millions of dollars are spent on enforcing prostitution laws every year and the San Francisco Crime Committee determined that spending on trying to control the issue buys essentially nothing of a positive nature. While the Atlantas Task Force on Prostitution believed it was a waste of money. They also believed that law enforcement didnt help much and little protection could be offered anyways. The problem could only be contained (Weitzer, 2000). Alternatives to the criminalization of prostitution was evaluated in this article. Decriminalization Decriminalization would eliminate forms of criminal penalties and would leave prostitution unregulated. There is virtually no public support of decriminalization and public policy makers are virtually opposed. Taken to the most serious level, decriminalization would allow prostitutes and their customers to engage sexually without restriction, except for prohibitions on public nudity and sex, (Weitzer, 2000). Legalization Legalization of prostitution would be the licensing or registration, confining prostitutes to red light districts, state-restricted brothels, mandatory medical exams, special business taxes, etc. The goal behind this tactic is that it would eliminate some of the above problems. However, the public seems to be divided on the issue, while policy makers seem to be silent on the issue as it would be condoning prostitution. Legalization confines prostitution to specific areas. In Nevada, where prostitution is legal in some areas, brothels are limited to small-scale operations in rural parts of Nevada. But this model still doesnt solve the problem of street prostitution in urban areas. To determine whether or not this tactic would be successful depends on a prostitutes willingness to move along with the regulations at hand. Prostitutes who have johns are sometimes not allowed to work in the zoned areas. Even with the stipulations, putting regulations who can work in the sex industry, some would still be excluded, forcing them to work illegally. Even with zoning, theres not a hundred percent that street prostitution would actually be confined to those zoned areas. Along with decriminalization, legalization has no foreseeable future (Weitzer, 2000). Two-track model With decriminalization and legislation both having an unforeseeable future, a two-track model was laid out. The first was indoor prostitution. That means, all forms of indoor prostitution including call girls, escort agencies and massage parlors would be legal. Claims made say that law enforcement spends countless hours and time in undercover operations related to indoor prostitution. So, by making it legalized, costs would be cut. In 1990, federal raids culminated a total of $2.5 million on a two-year undercover investigation. The second track proposed was restructuring street prostitution control. This model would enforce a greater awareness of streetwalkers and johns, strengthening the enforcement on the streets. This would also bring reform to the need for a more comprehensive program of meaningful job training and other needed services for those who want to leave prostitution. (Weitzer, 2000) Weitzer notes, Getting prostitutes off the streets requires positive incentives and assistance in the form of housing, job training, counseling, and drug treatment, but the dominant approach is overwhelmingly coercive rather than rehabilitative. Past experience abundantly shows the failure of narrowly punitive intervention. Without meaningful alternatives to prostitution there is little opportunity for a career change. Essentially, the two-track model outlined have advantages over decriminalization and legalization. It is superior for these reasons: public preferences regarding the proper focus of law enforcement, efficient use of criminal justice resources, and the harm-reduction principle. Key goals to this policy would be (1) redirecting control efforts from indoor to street prostitution, (2) gender-neutral law enforcement, and (3) providing support services and assistance for persons who want to leave prostitution, (Weitzer, 2000). Against prostitution strengths/weaknesses The other side is that any form of legalized prostitution increases sex trafficking and does not protect women. The Texas International Law Journal states, that legalized prostitution increases the demand for trafficking victims. When prostitution is legal, customers want unlimited access to these women, most of whom are culturally diverse, creating demand and a reason for international trade of women (Holman, 2009). Legalization also increases the Black Market. But, some scholars have disagreed and claimed that the legalization of prostitution reduces the black market. Katri Sieberg says, if it were legalized then the government†and not the organized criminals†would control it; and the government could gain from taxing it. However, it has not been proven accurate. In fact, black markets continue to flourish in areas where prostitution is legalized. Legalized prostitution is a traffickers best shield, allowing him to legitimize his trade in sex slaves and making it more difficult to identify trafficking victims. Even in countries where women are required to obtain a working permit to prove that they work there, several NGOs have discovered that traffickers involved in the black market illegally use the work permits and will coach women to refer to themselves as independent migrant sex workers. Some say the legalizing prostitution will help the women against abuse. They also claim that its a victimless crime because the woman is choosing to put herself in that position. American journalist John Stossel wrote: Dont prostitutes own their bodies? Shouldnt they be able to freely contract to use their bodies as they wish? Who was hurt here? This is a victimless crime. But prostitution is not a victimless crime. Prostitutes are still experiencing a high rate of abuse even in countries where it is legal and regulated. In an international study, 186 prostitutes were interviewed who were also victims of abuse. They claimed that even though it may have been a legalized brothel that had regulations, abuse was still a present factor. By legalizing prostitution, pimps and johns are given the position to become business man sexual entrepreneurs instead of criminals. A survey concluded that 76% of prostitutes in the US have been beaten by their pimp. Another frequent argument is that legalized prostitution will help to protect the womens health. Its true that health checks are required, However this only applies to the prostitutes, so it is only protecting the customer from risk of STDs. Some argue that legalizing prostitution will protect their health as most brothels will require them to have health exams. Some countries even enforce a strict condom policy, but theres no way to always ensure that happens. A lot of times, men will pay extra for sex without a condom. Because the women are desperate, a lot of times they will forgo their health in order to make more money. In a US survey of prostitutes, 45% stated that men had been abusive when asked to wear a condom. The womens pimps are not usually concerned with their health and will force them to not wear a condom if a customer will pay more. Furthermore, even if the women were protected from the violence of their pimps and customers, physical health with the use of condoms, their mental health would be ruined. A lot of times, the women will be repeatedly raped to be conditioned for a life of prostitution. Prostitutes are forced to service many men every day and often must meet quotas in order to get paid. Studies have shown that prostituted women often show the same psychological injuries as war veterans and tortured victims. Psychologist Melissa Farley also found that a study of 68% of prostitutes in nine different countries were diagnosed with PTSD (Holman, 2009). Raymond also states that the legalization of prostitution encourages men to purchase women and use them for their own sexual purposes. Many men who previously would not have risked buying women for sex now see prostitution as acceptable. When legal barriers disappear, so too do the social and ethical barriers to treating women as sexual merchandise. Legalization of prostitution sends the message to new generations of men and boys that women are sexual commodities and that prostitution is harmless fun. (Raymond, 2003). Legalization of prostitution does not enhance a womans choice. Most women did not choose prostitution from a range of other options. It was their only option. And they were desperate to feed themselves and their children survival strategies. In his studies, Raymond said that these women didnt choose prostitution out of a plethora of other options. Rather than consenting to prostitution, a prostituted woman more accurately complies with the extremely limited options available to her. Her compliance is required by the fact of having to adapt to conditions of inequality that are set by the customer who pays her to do what he wants her to do. Self-sovereignty Another article states that criminalization of prostitution violates the right of self-sovereignty in depriving individuals of important forms of control over their own minds and bodies, but non-legalization does not violate this right. Therefore, it suggested that as a matter of principle, to advocate decriminalization but to oppose legalization. (Marneffe, 2012) Likewise, I will say that prostitution is criminalized when there are criminal penalties for the sale of sexual services. Prostitution is decriminalized when there are no criminal penalties for the sale of sexual services. Prostitution is legalized when there are no criminal penalties for operating a sex business, such as a brothel or escort service, and no criminal penalties for acting as a paid agent for sexual services, and no penalties for purchasing these services from anyone above the age of sexual consent and legal employment. Marneffe claims that by criminalizing prostitution, you are taking away a persons ability to have control over their own mind and body, which is taking away their right to self-sovereignty. But by non-legalizing prostitution, you are not prohibiting those rights. Laws that prohibit someone from selling their body for a service and doing what they want with it is taking away a moral right. But laws that obstruct someones ability to own a brothel does not take away a moral right because the person still has control over their mind and body. He believes self-sovereignty means, We have the right to decide what to reflect on, what to daydream about, what to imagine, what experiences to have in our minds using our own bodies, and what moods to try to be in. We have a right to decide what to put into our bodies, how to take care of our bodies, how to use our bodies for our own benefit, work or pleasure. At the same time, it doesnt mean that right has no parameters. Marneffe gave this example: A man does not have the right throw his body off the top of a skyscraper no matter who might be below. So, because of this, there needs of be a theory of self-sovereignty in place to make clear the conditions to which the government can interfere when it comes to limiting an individuals control over their mind and body. One possible theory he proposed was in Mills One Liberty: the government may limit an adults liberty against his will in ways that can be justified as protecting others from harm, (Marneffe, 2012).

Essay on Contrasting The Religions of Christianity and...

The world has many different belief systems including Christianity and Buddhism. Both are similar and different in many ways. These religions are used in different places around the world and influenced the lives of its followers and the society in which they are practiced. Christianity is more diverse and complicated in its beliefs and totally depends on faith. In contrast, Hinduism is a belief more based on the simplicity of culture and tradition. Christianity was founded in the early first century. It is centered around the belief of the resurrection of Jesus Christ. It is the largest religion in the world with around 2 billion followers. Christianity is a monotheistic religion. This means that Christians believe in only one†¦show more content†¦Mary was a human being who gave birth to Jesus Christ through immaculate conception. Angels are believed to be spiritual beings created by God before the world was created. They exist to glorify God, minister to God, and to act as messengers to the people on Earth. In Christian belief, demons are angels who rebelled against God and were banished from the heavens. The leader of the rebellious angels is Satan. Heaven is believed to be a place in which believers have freedom from suffering and sin in the presence of God. Hell is a place in the afterlife where sinners are punished. This belief system influences people to live a good, spiritual life dedicated to God and to do good deeds in order to enter the kingdom of God called heaven. Worshipers follow the Ten Commandments such as â€Å"Thou shall not steal† and â€Å"Thou shall not kill† in order to be good Christians and be blessed by the Lord our Father. Christianity, if practiced literally, it would altogether eliminate wars and bring peace to the world. Christianity introduced schools in churches and monasteries to educate the poor and nobility. Christianity also influenced artists in the works that they produced. Music has also been influenced such as gospel and spiritual songs. The symbol of the Cross has been used in many different ways such as jewelry with a variety of metals and jewels (gold, silver, gems etc.). Hinduism is an ancient religion with no known founder or date ofShow MoreRelatedSimilarities Between Christianity And Hinduism1166 Words   |  5 PagesBy definition, religion is considered as, â€Å" the belief in and worship of a god or group of gods.â₠¬  Various religions can be found internationally and many are practiced worldwide. Both Christianity and Hinduism are very popular religions, and have a substantial amount of followers. In fact, Christianity and Hinduism are the largest, and third largest religions of the world, respectively. They have been tremendously influential on the world and have, arguably, shaped it into what it is today. DespiteRead MoreChristianity And Hinduism : A Theological Perspective1391 Words   |  6 PagesWhen looking at Christianity and Hinduism there are many ways to look at each religion from a theological perspective. This is why the best way to look at the broad view of these religions would be to analyze each by comparing and contrasting what each religion is about. The first point to look at would be at how Hinduism and Christianity are very similar in how they view the world. This can be seen in how they both strive to achieve a state of higher being whether it be with the eternal sta teRead MoreReligion And Its Impact On Religion Essay1277 Words   |  6 PagesReligion can be one of the most controversial topics in conversation due to difference of opinion not to mention beliefs. People have individualism, free will, and culture that determines the way to live life as well as perspectives about the afterlife. Wars have continued through centuries over religious perspectives and dissimilar beliefs even though there are many similar traits within major religions worldwide. Time continues to move although lives are lost over mistrust, hate and divide ofRead MoreCompare and Contrast Buddhism and Christianity1311 Words   |  6 PagesReligion is one of the oldest and most sacred traditions of the human species. Religion started off as a basic belief in an afterlife, and then further developed into tribal religions, which evolved into ancestral worship, then to polytheism, and lastly into monotheism. Monotheism in the form of Christianity is the largest religio n of the modern world, and it has similar beliefs to other world religions such as Buddhism. Christianity and Buddhism are similar because both religions teach aboutRead MoreSimilarities and Differences Between Christianity Hinduism1635 Words   |  7 PagesExamine and comment on contrasting standpoints about God and/or existence in relation to the topic you have investigated. Christianity and Hinduism seem to have profoundly different views in relation to God and/or existence. For example, creation within Christian belief is primarily ex-nihilo (out of nothing). God created everything in 7 days from the light and darkness, to the day of rest. This can be illustrated by reference to Genesis 1:1 – 2:4a â€Å"In the beginning God created the heavens andRead MoreThe Importance Of The Religion Of Hinduism And Hinduism849 Words   |  4 PagesReligion is an important component of culture and cultural identity. The strength of its practice could depend on the location. For the Religion of Hinduism, heavy influence is held all across India. Hinduism holds many contrasting values and practices from the religion of Christianity. The first notable instance of the Hindu religion when opposed to Christianity is that while the Christians believe in 3 deities (The Holy Trinity), The Hindu religion holds the belief that there are many deitiesRead MoreThe Social Question And Existential Question Of Religion793 Words   |  4 Pagesand the existential question of religions have always played a huge role in the implementation of individuals to communities and its connection to God’s or a divine figure’s plan in the universe. Therefore by comparing, contrasting and assessing the religions of Christianity and Hinduism this essay will seek to answer both the social question of human unity and the existential questions of human relation to a divine being’s plan for the universe. For Christianity the social question of how and whyRead MoreA Look into Hinduism Essay example763 Words   |  4 Pagesmakes Hinduism so strange. Hinduism lacks an uniting belief system and many people do not know faithfully what makes up the Hindu religious belief. After one goes in-depth concerning Hinduism, one must be familiar with the fundamental details about this difficult religion. Do you realize that almost 80 percent of the India people find themselves being Hindus? Hinduism is in addition known as the Sanatana-Dharma, which means everlasting religion. Hinduism is the third leading religion followingRead MoreAnalysis of Hinduism and Islam651 Words   |  3 Pages Amongst the various religions practice are Islam and Hinduism. Both of these religions are widely practiced by people who believe in the same ideals or concepts. These separate religions are similar to one another, but also contrasting. Common themes can be found between Hinduism and Islam, but the differences are predominant as well. Those who practice Islam are typically Arabic and are called Muslim’s. This practice is based off of the text called the Qur’an. The Qur’an is a bible of sorts toRead MoreThey Are Staring At Me And My Aunt Gold Teeth1226 Words   |  5 Pagesand other Sikhs. In â€Å"My Aunt Gold Teeth,† the reader experiences Gold Teeth s religious inspirations and conflicts through the viewpoint of her nephew. Considering these similarities, Naipaul contrasts the third person viewpoint, the meaning of religion, and the characteristics of wealth between the stories to express different aspects of Indian life. In both stories, Naipaul uses third person viewpoints; however, each story has a different third person perspective. Throughout â€Å"They Are Staring

Good Parenting free essay sample

Parenting is indeed a full time job, and there is never a perfect parent. There are judgments made by people in today’s society saying how one parent is better than the other, but by who’s standards? I believe that I’ve narrowed the â€Å"standards to good parenting† down to three main points. One, when a parent provides their child with a valuable sense or morals and character. Two, when a parent provides the best they can for their child. What I mean by that statement is when a parent takes the necessary responsibilities and actions to raise their own child. Last but not least, a parent is someone their child can go and talk to. When these standards are met, the parent has succeeded. When someone becomes a parent, the pressure is on. Responsibilities must be taken in order to provide for the child. For example, one may take on an extra job to help be financially stable. We will write a custom essay sample on Good Parenting or any similar topic specifically for you Do Not WasteYour Time HIRE WRITER Only 13.90 / page By having this extra money things become more flexible and stable in the household. Parents can afford school supplies, food, clothes and a shelter for their child. When a parent provides for their child, it gives the parent a sense of pride. A responsible adult also makes sacrifices. It may be not getting their nails done every other week like they used to, or, it may be just spending more time with them. If a parent does this for their child, then they are on the right side of parenting. Second step to good parenting, is being a child’s best friend. As a parent, the child should feel comfortable coming to their parent for anything. They could be asked for advice or they may just want their parent to listen to them. Either way, the child shows that they have trust in the relationship with their parent. Knowing that their child can trust you is a huge accomplishment. If a parent does not succeed at becoming their child’s friend, things can get pretty difficult. The child begins to sneak and lie about certain things in hopes that the parent won’t care about what is really going on. Sooner or later, the child begins to get into more and more trouble which provides stress upon the parent and family. Nobody wants this outcome for their child or family, so being there for the child and becoming their friend is one of the best things a parent can do. Last but not least, any good parent guides their child and provides them with a good set of moral values and character. These traits can be passed down from generation to generation or learned throughout the course of life. Character is what the child develops while growing up, but the parents are the ones who guide them and shape the way they grow. They provide an outline that will stick with them for many years to come. Later on in life, they will become a parent and hopefully pass their traits and values along to their kin. There are many more qualities that parents can have to be called a good parent, but I believe these three are the most important. These three â€Å"standards† have a big impact on their child’s life and that’s why I think they are the most important. No matter what, people are going to have their own standards and opinions but that doesn’t make you a bad parent if you don’t follow their rules. You are a good parent when you do the best you can do for your child, if you are there for your child and last but not least, if you have provided a good sense of moral values.